Scottie Scheffler Rejects Rory McIlroy’s Bold Tiger Woods Comparison Amid U.S. Open Buzz

As the golfing world gears up for the 2025 U.S. Open at Oakmont Country Club, a compelling narrative has emerged involving two of the sport’s biggest stars, Scottie Scheffler and Rory McIlroy. The headline-grabbing story centers on McIlroy’s recent claim comparing Scheffler’s dominance to that of the legendary Tiger Woods—a comparison Scheffler has humbly but firmly dismissed. This exchange has added intrigue to an already highly anticipated major championship, where both players are among the top contenders vying for glory

.

The Context: McIlroy’s High Praise for Scheffler

Rory McIlroy, a five-time major champion and one of golf’s most prominent figures, sparked the conversation earlier this year when he drew parallels between Scheffler’s remarkable consistency and the prime years of Tiger Woods. Speaking after Scheffler’s commanding victory at the 2025 PGA Championship at Quail Hollow, McIlroy marveled at the world No. 1’s ability to string together bogey-free rounds. “I’ve never – this is anyone, this is Tiger, this is in the history of golf – I don’t think I’ve ever seen a golfer play as many bogey-free rounds as Scottie,” McIlroy said, according to reports from The Mirror US.

McIlroy’s comments were rooted in Scheffler’s extraordinary 2024 and early 2025 seasons, during which he cemented his status as the game’s preeminent player. Scheffler’s victories at the Masters, the PGA Championship, and multiple PGA Tour events showcased a level of precision and mental fortitude that drew inevitable comparisons to Woods, who dominated golf with 15 major titles and an unmatched aura of invincibility in the late 1990s and early 2000s. McIlroy, who has long been vocal about his admiration for Woods, seemed to suggest that Scheffler’s current trajectory mirrors the relentless consistency that defined Woods’ prime.

However, McIlroy’s praise came with a tinge of concern. His own form has been inconsistent since his Masters triumph earlier this year, a stark contrast to Scheffler’s relentless momentum. 

McIlroy’s struggles were evident at the PGA Championship, where he finished 15 shots behind Scheffler, and at the RBC Canadian Open, where a 1-over 71 in the opening round left him frustrated. McIlroy admitted to equipment issues, particularly with his driver, and expressed frustration over a leak that incorrectly suggested he was the one dealing with equipment woes when it was actually Scheffler’s driver that had failed earlier in the week. “I was a little pissed off because I knew that Scottie’s driver had failed on Monday, but my name was the one that was leaked,” McIlroy said, as reported by Yahoo Sports. This incident highlighted the intense scrutiny both players face as they prepare for the U.S. Open.

Scheffler’s Response: Humility Over Hype

While McIlroy’s comparison was meant as a compliment, Scottie Scheffler was quick to downplay the parallels to Tiger Woods. Speaking after defending his Hero World Challenge title late last year, Scheffler expressed deep respect for Woods but rejected the notion that his achievements rival those of the golfing icon. “I have so much respect for Tiger and what he’s done for the game,” Scheffler said, as quoted by The Mirror US. “But I don’t think it’s fair to compare anyone to him. He’s in a league of his own.”

Scheffler’s humility is characteristic of his grounded approach to stardom. Despite his meteoric rise, which includes multiple major championships and a stranglehold on the world No. 1 ranking, the 28-year-old Texan has consistently deflected comparisons to golf’s all-time greats. His focus remains on the process—fine-tuning his game, staying disciplined, and avoiding the distractions of hype. This mindset has served him well, as evidenced by his recent dominance, including a wire-to-wire victory at Quail Hollow, where he outpaced the field, including McIlroy, in convincing fashion.

Scheffler’s rejection of the Woods comparison also reflects his awareness of the unique pressures that come with being labeled the “next Tiger.” Woods’ career was defined not only by his 82 PGA Tour wins but also by his ability to perform under unprecedented scrutiny. Scheffler, while dominant, operates in a different era, one with a deeper and more competitive field, including players like McIlroy, Bryson DeChambeau, and Jon Rahm, all of whom are expected to challenge at Oakmont.

The U.S. Open Spotlight

The timing of this exchange couldn’t be more significant, as the 2025 U.S. Open looms large. Oakmont, known for its punishing layout and fast greens, is set to host the year’s third major starting June 12. Scheffler enters as the betting favorite at +320 odds, followed closely by McIlroy at +550 and defending champion Bryson DeChambeau at +900, according to CBS Sports. The course’s demanding setup favors players with precision and mental toughness, qualities Scheffler has in spades.

Broadcaster Brandel Chamblee has even gone so far as to predict that the U.S. Open is “Scheffler’s for the taking.” Responding to a question on X about the likely winning score at Oakmont, Chamblee quipped, “Whatever Scottie Scheffler shoots.” This sentiment underscores the golfing world’s confidence in Scheffler’s ability to handle any challenge, particularly after his recent major triumphs.

McIlroy, on the other hand, faces questions about his form. His Masters victory was a high point, but his inability to capitalize at Quail Hollow—where he has historically excelled—raised eyebrows. McIlroy’s decision to skip media obligations for four straight days at the PGA Championship fueled speculation about his mental state, and his recent comments about his driver suggest he’s still searching for consistency off the tee. Despite these challenges, McIlroy’s pedigree as the 2011 U.S. Open champion and his familiarity with Oakmont make him a formidable contender.

The Shadow of Tiger Woods

The comparisons to Tiger Woods add an extra layer of intrigue to the Scheffler-McIlroy dynamic. Woods, now 49 and limited by injuries, is no longer a regular contender in majors, but his legacy looms large. McIlroy’s invocation of Woods’ name was a nod to Scheffler’s ability to avoid mistakes, a hallmark of Woods’ game during his prime. However, Scheffler’s reluctance to embrace the comparison highlights the different paths these players have taken. Woods was a global phenomenon whose charisma transcended golf, while Scheffler’s rise has been quieter, built on relentless consistency rather than flash.

Interestingly, Woods himself has praised Scheffler’s game, noting his ball-striking and composure under pressure. Yet Scheffler’s insistence on carving his own path suggests he’s more focused on writing his own legacy than living in Woods’ shadow. For McIlroy, the comparison may also reflect his own aspirations. As one of the few active players with multiple majors, McIlroy has long been seen as a potential heir to Woods’ throne, but his recent struggles have shifted the spotlight to Scheffler.

What’s at Stake at Oakmont

The 2025 U.S. Open promises to be a defining moment for both Scheffler and McIlroy. For Scheffler, a victory would further solidify his status as the game’s dominant force and could spark renewed discussions about his place among golf’s all-time greats. For McIlroy, a second U.S. Open title would quiet doubts about his form and bring him closer to completing the career Grand Slam, a feat he achieved at the Masters earlier this year.

The field at Oakmont will be stacked, with Bryson DeChambeau looking to defend his title after edging out McIlroy at Pinehurst in 2024. Jon Rahm, Xander Schauffele, and Collin Morikawa are also among the top names expected to contend. Yet the narrative surrounding Scheffler and McIlroy—amplified by McIlroy’s bold comparison and Scheffler’s measured response—will likely dominate the conversation.

Conclusion

As the golfing world descends on Oakmont, the Scheffler-McIlroy dynamic adds a compelling subplot to an already blockbuster event. McIlroy’s attempt to elevate Scheffler to Tiger Woods’ level reflects the immense respect he has for his rival, but it also underscores the pressure both players face in their quest for greatness. Scheffler’s rejection of the comparison is a testament to his humility and focus, qualities that have made him nearly unbeatable in recent years. Whether McIlroy can overcome his recent struggles and challenge Scheffler at the U.S. Open remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: the golfing world will be watching closely as these two titans battle for supremacy on one of the sport’s grandest stages.